Waterfront residence featuring a private boat lift, a screened-in rear enclosure, a stone-paved patio, and a tile roof

1 / 50

187 Eveningstar Cay, Naples, FL 34114

$729,000 For Sale

Beds
3
Baths
2
Sq Ft
1,458
Built
2022

Price cut $10,500 13 days ago

MLS# 226026739 111 days on market

Fees & taxes

Annual fees
$2,676
One-time fees
$350
Seller’s 2025 taxes
$6,789

Community

Port of the Islands
Subdivision Eveningstar Cay

Questions about this home?
Ask about this home or arrange a tour.

Listing description

Lowest priced single-family home with direct water access in Collier County. Welcome to waterfront living at its finest in the sought- after, direct Gulf-access community of Port of the Islands. Built in 2023, this exceptional waterfront residence offers the perfect blend of modern coastal luxury, quality craftsmanship, and effortless boating access. This beautifully designed 3-bedroom, 2-bath home showcases elegant finishes, an open-concept layout, and a light-filled interior created for comfortable everyday living and entertaining. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, seasonal retreat, or investment opportunity, this home delivers style, comfort, and value. Step outside to your private waterfront setting, where your backyard provides direct boating access to the Gulf of America through the spectacular Ten Thousand Islands. Spend your days fishing, cruising, kayaking, or exploring secluded beaches and world-renowned backwaters right from your own dock. Perfectly positioned near Everglades National Park, this boating paradise offers endless opportunities for outdoor adventure, wildlife viewing, and some of Southwest Florida's finest fishing. Experience the tranquility of waterfront living while remaining within easy reach of Naples' shopping, dining, golf courses, and pristine Gulf beaches. If you've been searching for new construction waterfront living in the Naples area at an exceptional value, this is the opportunity you've been waiting for.

Property details

Building & ownership

Ownership
Single Family
Furnishings
Unfurnished
Building style
Ranch, Single Family
Floor plan
Great Room
Construction
Concrete Block, Stucco
Roof
Tile
Lot size
0.11 acres
Lot description
Regular

Interior

Features
Walk-In Closet(s)
Flooring
Tile
Cooling
Central Electric
Bedroom details
First Floor Bedroom
Additional rooms
Laundry in Residence, Screened Lanai/Porch

Kitchen & dining

Appliances
Dishwasher, Dryer, Microwave, Range, Refrigerator, Washer
Dining
Dining - Living

Outdoor & view

View
Canal
Rear exposure
North
Exterior
Dock Included, Screened Lanai/Porch
Storm protection
Impact Resistant Windows

Parking

Garage
Yes
Car port
No
Spots
2
Description
Attached

Pool & spa

Private pool
No
Private spa
No
Community pool
Yes
Pool description
Community

Waterfront

Waterfront
Yes
Description
Canal Front
Gulf access
Yes
Gulf access type
No Bridge(s)/Water Direct
Canal
None
Boat / dock
Dock Included

Community amenities

Amenities
Pool
Elevator
None

What the fees cover

Maintenance
Lawn/Land Maintenance, Manager

Pets & leasing

Pets allowed
Yes
Leases per year
3
Minimum lease
30 days
Restrictions
Architectural

Additional details

Parcel number
31417501705
Potential short sale
No

Listing last updated October 30, 2026

Listing courtesy of Engel & Volkers Marco Island · 239-963-4223

Property taxes for a new owner

Estimated property taxes about $7,200 a year at the county’s value of this home and its 1.24% tax rate, plus $983 in charges not based on value, no exemptions applied

That is about the same as the seller’s bill on the county’s 2026 roll.

If you make this home your primary residence, a homestead exemption would lower this figure. If you have also had a Florida homestead in any of the last three years, you may be able to carry up to $500,000 of its capped-value savings to this home, which Florida calls “portability.” Both are applied for with the Property Appraiser by March 1.

How a new owner’s property taxes are set is explained in the Costs & Taxes chapter of the 2027 Naples Buyer’s Guide.

Estimated from the Collier County Property Appraiser’s 2026 value of this home and its tax rate, plus its 2025 charges not based on value from the Collier County Tax Collector’s roll. The county sets a new value each January 1, so a new owner’s first full bill can differ.

Destinations & driving times from 187 Eveningstar Cay

Every destination named here is described in the Destinations chapter of the 2027 Naples Buyer’s Guide.

Driving times are estimated from this home’s location, using OpenStreetMap road data.

Dining & Shopping near 187 Eveningstar Cay – #226026739, by driving distance
NameMilesETA
Fifth Avenue South 22.6 mi 34 min
Third Street South 23.7 mi 37 min
Coastland Center 24.7 mi 39 min
Venetian Village 26.8 mi 43 min
Waterside Shops 27.8 mi 44 min
Galleria Shoppes at Vanderbilt 28.8 mi 45 min
Mercato 30.6 mi 48 min
Miromar Outlets 43.6 mi 58 min
Coconut Point 44.4 mi 61 min
Gulf Coast Town Center 48 mi 62 min

Flood zones & evacuation

Two different things, measured by two different agencies. Evacuation zones are about storm surge and who leaves first. Flood zones are FEMA’s insurance rating, and they vary from home to home.

Hurricane evacuation zone

Zone A Collier

The first zone ordered to evacuate, and the one called in the weakest storms.

Called firstCalled last
FEMA flood zone

Zone AE

1% annual chance, with a set base flood elevation

The lot is inside a Special Flood Hazard Area, where a federally backed mortgage requires flood insurance.

FEMA flood maps and Collier County Emergency Management. A revised Collier County flood map is in preparation and may change these zones.

A starting point, not a determination. Your lender will require its own flood zone determination before closing, and your insurer will normally require an elevation certificate — a surveyor’s measurement of how high the building actually sits — before quoting. Those documents govern; this does not replace either. Zones can also be amended individually through FEMA.

Flood zones, evacuation, and insurance are explained in the Risk, Resilience & Insurance chapter of the 2027 Naples Buyer’s Guide.

Flood zones across Port of the Islands

Jeffrey Waldman

Jeffrey Waldman

REALTOR® and Owner, Naples Abodes

Call (239) 450-3763 Text (239) 450-3763

Florida License SL3295589

“You won't go wrong with Jeff at your side!”
Bill & Joyce Robertson

Ask me about this home

How should I reply?

Schedule a tour of this home

Pick a day and a time that suit you. I will confirm it with you.