5134 Kensington High St., Naples, FL 34105 – #224105073

1 / 44

5134 Kensington High St., Naples, FL 34105

$2,100,000 Sold

Beds
3
Baths
3½
Sq Ft
3,450
Built
1995

MLS# 224105073 Listed at $2,375,000 Sold May 7, 2025

Fees & taxes

Annual fees
$7,304
One-time fees
$2,704
Seller’s 2023 taxes
$7,700

Questions about this home?
Ask about this home or what available homes are like it.

Listing description

Welcome to the Kensington Country Club Community! This 3 bed+den/3(1) baths custom Arthur Rutenburg home is a masterpiece of timeless elegance, thoughtfully crafted to offer a seamless blend of comfort and versatility for every lifestyle. From the moment you step into the stunning two-story foyer, the home's grandeur unfolds, with a regal curved staircase and gleaming wood floors setting the tone for a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Spread across two levels, this home offers an abundance of spaces to suit every occasion. The comfortable living room with a gas fireplace, inviting dining room, and versatile bar/entertainment room flow effortlessly into the serene sunroom, the perfect morning retreat. A study with extensive built-ins provides a quiet workspace, while the lanai, complete with a sparkling pool, beckons for outdoor enjoyment. The pool heater, variable speed pump, and Jandy Wi-Fi control system (2024) ensure your enjoyment year-round. The heart of the home is the classical kitchen, outfitted with Custom wood cabinets, high-end appliances, including a GE Profile refrigerator (2024), a Thermador wall oven with a warming tray, and a sprawling island with a built-in dining table ideal for meal prep, casual dining, or entertaining. Upstairs offers a gracious loft that leads to two spacious guest suites, one being ensuite, offering both comfort and privacy for visitors. There is also a family room that could easily be a 4th sleeping space with close access to a full bathroom. The luxurious, spa-inspired primary ensuite bath features an elegant double vanity, built-in- tub, and walk-in shower, while one oversized walk-in closet has a double-door entry that enhances the suite's appeal. Additional highlights include plantation shutters throughout, 2 car garage plus golf cart garage, a Mitsubishi mini-split garage air conditioner (2021), and a Culligan whole-house water system with reverse osmosis filtration (2023). A newer roof (2019) and a completed gutter system add value and peace of mind to the house. This residence offers an unparalleled fusion of refined elegance, ultimate comfort, and situated on the 9th hole of the pristine golf course—creating an extraordinary living experience that effortlessly combines luxury with everyday convenience. A delicious bonus is enjoying Bananas and Myers lemons picked fresh from your own trees!

Property details

Building & ownership

Ownership
Single Family
Furnishings
Unfurnished
Building style
Two Story, Single Family
Floor plan
2 Story
Construction
Concrete Block, Stucco
Roof
Tile
Lot size
0.23 acres
Lot description
Golf Course, Regular

Interior

Features
Built-In Cabinets, Closet Cabinets, Custom Mirrors, Fireplace, Foyer, French Doors, Laundry Tub, Smoke Detectors, Volume Ceiling, Walk-In Closet(s), Window Coverings
Flooring
Wood
Cooling
Ceiling Fan(s), Central Electric
Additional rooms
Den - Study, Family Room, Glass Porch, Laundry in Residence, Loft, Screened Lanai/Porch

Kitchen & dining

Kitchen
Island
Appliances
Cooktop, Dishwasher, Double Oven, Dryer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Warming Tray, Washer
Dining
Eat-in Kitchen, Formal

Outdoor & view

View
Golf Course
Rear exposure
East
Exterior
Glass Porch, Screened Lanai/Porch
Storm protection
None

Parking

Garage
Yes
Car port
No
Spots
3
Description
Attached

Pool & spa

Private pool
Yes
Private spa
No
Pool description
Below Ground, Concrete, Electric Heat, Screen Enclosure

Waterfront

Waterfront
No
Description
None
Gulf access
No
Canal
None
Boat / dock
None

Community amenities

Amenities
Private Membership, Sidewalk, Streetlight, Underground Utility
Golf
Golf Equity, Golf Non Equity
Elevator
None
Security
Smoke Detector(s), Gated Community

What the fees cover

Maintenance
Cable, Irrigation Water, Lawn/Land Maintenance, Manager, Master Assn. Fee Included, Security

Pets & leasing

Pets allowed
Limits
Number allowed
2
Leases per year
3
Minimum lease
30 days
Restrictions
Architectural, Deeded, No Commercial, No RV, No Truck

Schools

Elementary
Osceola Elementary
Middle
Pine Ridge Middle
High
Barron Collier High

Additional details

Parcel number
52730008906
Potential short sale
No

Listing last updated May 7, 2025

Premiere Plus Realty Company · 239-732-7837

Destinations & driving times from 5134 Kensington High St

Every destination named here is described in the Destinations chapter of the 2027 Naples Buyer’s Guide.

Driving times are estimated from this home’s location, using OpenStreetMap road data.

Dining & Shopping near 5134 Kensington High St., Naples, FL 34105 – #224105073, by driving distance
NameMilesETA
Waterside Shops 3.5 mi 9 min
Galleria Shoppes at Vanderbilt 3.7 mi 9 min
Venetian Village 5 mi 12 min
Coastland Center 5.9 mi 14 min
Mercato 5.9 mi 13 min
Fifth Avenue South 7.8 mi 17 min
Third Street South 8.9 mi 20 min
Coconut Point 16.4 mi 29 min
Miromar Outlets 18.7 mi 27 min
Gulf Coast Town Center 23.1 mi 30 min

Flood zones & evacuation

Two different things, measured by two different agencies. Evacuation zones are about storm surge and who leaves first. Flood zones are FEMA’s insurance rating, and they vary from home to home.

Hurricane evacuation zone

Zone C Collier

Called in the third wave, for stronger storms.

Called firstCalled last
FEMA flood zone

Mostly Zone X (minimal)

Minimal mapped flood hazard

The building is outside the Special Flood Hazard Area. Part of it lies in another zone.

FEMA flood maps and Collier County Emergency Management. A revised Collier County flood map is in preparation and may change these zones.

A starting point, not a determination. Your lender will require its own flood zone determination before closing, and your insurer will normally require an elevation certificate — a surveyor’s measurement of how high the building actually sits — before quoting. Those documents govern; this does not replace either. Zones can also be amended individually through FEMA.

Flood zones, evacuation, and insurance are explained in the Risk, Resilience & Insurance chapter of the 2027 Naples Buyer’s Guide.

Flood zones across Kensington

Jeffrey Waldman

Jeffrey Waldman

REALTOR® and Owner, Naples Abodes

Call (239) 450-3763 Text (239) 450-3763

Florida License SL3295589

“I hit the jackpot with Jeff Waldman.”
Jim Yanci

Ask me about this home

How should I reply?

Or book a call with me

Pick a day and a time that suit you and I will call.